Construction phase – onshore
Feedback was received on the temporary social impacts on communities and public roads in the form of traffic restrictions and disturbance to residents and road users. We are keenly aware of and wish to minimise any impacts on local communities in the development of this critical infrastructure. Mitigating against impact to communities during the construction phase is a priority for NISA and measures to manage this are detailed in the EIAR. The team continues to engage with local communities to gather feedback to ensure it can be delivered in the most appropriate manner.
Distance of turbines to shore
Throughout the consultation phase with the community, there were questions as to why the turbines could not be positioned further from the shore. The project team and the community liaison team detailed the survey works that led to the final proposed development layout as well as the technology that was available that would facilitate a fixed bottom foundation suitable for the seabed depth and ground conditions. In order to viably construct an offshore wind farm that has its foundations fixed into the seabed the maximum water depth considered to be feasible is recognised to be approximately 60m. Fixed bottom foundations cannot be located further from the shore, as Ireland’s seabed depth increases very quickly as you move from the shore.
Changes to the design and total number of WTGs
The most appropriate layouts being presented are based on a number of influences including the ground conditions, site output and the marine environment. Survey works continued since our last consultation event giving us more information on those topics and influenced a further tweak to the layout. Technology in offshore wind is developing faster than it has before. The planning application allows for flexibility for NISA by presenting two layout options. One with 35 wind turbine generators (WTGs) with a maximum tip height of 316m and one with 49 WTGs with a maximum tip height of 290m. This will ensure the project can avail of the most suitable technology at the time of construction.
Onshore infrastructure
There were also concerns raised about the grid facility which would be located north of Balbriggan, west of the R132. We recognised that this is a new type of infrastructure for the area so measures to screen the infrastructure to minimise any visual impact were displayed as part of the public consultation and on the website.
No impact or damage to beaches or coastline
Several people expressed concern about the potential impact to the area of coastline in which cables would come onshore. For this project, both open-cut and trenchless drilling methods were considered. Trenchless has been deemed the most appropriate option as feedback from our engagement process was that people would rather not see the coastline disturbed. We are confident that this methodology can be applied.
Visuals
The visual aspect of NISA has always been a very important consideration. As part of the design process, visual impact assessments were carried out and photomontages of how the proposal will look were prepared.
The process for preparing the photomontages is rigorous, scientifically accurate and involves the use of sophisticated software. The turbines are modelled in 3D to their correct dimensions and placed into a digital terrain model of the whole 60km radius study area in their exact positions. The 3D terrain model with the proposed turbines in it are then matched to the baseline photography at each of the viewpoints in a precise 360-degree overlay. They are extremely accurate in terms of location and size and the process does not require any mathematic calculations that could incur errors. It is an industry standard process governed by strict guidelines.
Environment
Feedback was received regarding potential impacts the project could have on marine life, sea birds and mammals as well as the local environment. The afore-mentioned Environmental Impact Assessment Report (EIAR) considers the potential impacts of the construction, operational and maintenance and decommissioning phases of the proposed development, both on and offshore. In NISA, as with all our projects, we will be doing our utmost to avoid any negative impacts on the surrounding areas while seeking opportunities to enhance biodiversity and the local environment. The project team is considering the sustainability of this project through the various stages of construction and operation with the view to ensuring that the project is delivered in the most environmentally appropriate manner.
Community Benefit Fund
In the case of the proposed development a Community Benefit Fund could reach approximately €4million each year or €80 million over the lifetime of the project –giving residents the opportunity to bring about transformative and positive change to their local community. The community had questions on the administration and distribution of this fund. In time, an independent Fund Administrator will be appointed to facilitate and support the local community to maximise the opportunities of the Community Benefit Fund. Since 2019, the project team has been engaging with local community groups on the process with a view to aggregating information, feedback and submissions which could guide the direction of the Community Benefit Fund.